
It is a truth Gazally acknowledged that girls, those unmarried in particular, do not usually go alone after dark. This week, however, was pretty interesting for me. It brought with its beginnings two meetings with some internationals which, for my normal fortune, have to take place after feast, that is to say after it’s dark.
Never mind. I have never let darkness assume its control over my own life. In fact, I would simply use my secret tender weapon against it: My mother. My mother, who probably would be the last person to break any of our social rules, is just another typical Gazan with such a conservative mentality which many times for a long time I’ve considered unpleasant. Telling her about such meetings is probably the hardest part. I start very confident:
“Mom, guess what?! Today some internationals came to work and we had some really interesting talk.” She grins kindly showing some interest, “and you know what, they wanted to make an interview with us, and it would be videotaped.”
“Good for you, when is that?”
“Well, mother. 8 o’clock” I say, less confident.
“Isn’t that too early?”
“8 in the evening, mom!” knowing that she would not ask me to cancel it nor would she give me an immediate approval, I always have to wait till she think the matter over in her mind again and again as if she had not done it like tens of times before and she already has a set answer.
“Well, ok. I’ll be going with you then.”
Never has this matter had the least effect upon my life whether academically or socially. I can always take my mother along with me to any social occasion that might take place after darkness.
“Oh, very nice”, said Emmy, one of the three internationals I’ve met in the office the other day, shaking her head impressed by what one of my colleagues declared so proudly that her parents being very different and of a really opened mentality would let her go out at night with no companion. Their faces, however, frowned with a pitiful look when I simply said I’m not allowed to go out at night.
Their pitiful looks would not have surprised me at all, but what really hurt was the “Thank God for my parents” I heard from one of my colleagues. Astonished by the fact that I’m being hinted to have a family with a “backward mentality” or “not-illuminated free” family by one of my own people, I think I naturally started acting aggressive.
“It’s ok; I could always bring my mother with me. She can drop me by any time I want” A smile was drawn in Emmy’s face who must have thought this very interesting as she said excitedly, “She’s very welcome. I would love to meet her.” My other two colleagues were exchanging sarcastic looks and giggling, and then took the role of explaining to the international that unlike lots of other families, theirs are very fine and would give them the freedom to go out even at night which is something that many other “poor girls” do not have. I would not deny it; I did shoot them a scornful look.
The first thing “Emmy” got to ask me the next day when I arrived at the center after my mother dropped me there was “Where is your mother?”
She was then surprised when I told her that she dropped me by and went to a family visit as usual. “I thought she would be waiting for you here till you finish” said Emmy. I do not think I would give my mother such a torture. She never has limited my choices or restrained my freedom and never have I restrained hers. Well, to some extent.
I was expecting their following questions which is a common feature I have felt in most of internationals whom I met so far. They always try to investigate whether women are being oppressed in the society or not, whether they are happy with their position or not, and they are so good at the feminist talk of women’s right. Explaining that it is something to do with our parents protective nature, especially when it comes to females, besides religion and social customs and traditions, the subject swiftly drifted to more interesting subjects involving Literature “Shakespeare, George Eliot, Jane Austen, Suad Amiry, Edward Said” and many others. I was actually surprised to know that “Sharon and my mother in Law” was first published in Italy as Shantal, the other Italian international, told me.
When both my colleagues arrived an hour later, we had to start videotaping a discussion revolving around international role in the Gaza Strip. The discussion went pretty well till one of my colleagues stupidly repeated her remark about she being one of the elites whose parents have no problem letting her go out in the darkness UNLIKE others who do not enjoy such advantage. Obviously, another intended “Pity you and lucky me” or let’s say “You should be looking into the bright side of Gaza”.
That’s it. This has to be put to an end. Turning very aggressive this time, I guess I started talking about how internationals should really respect cultural differences. I’m from a different culture. If your parents allow you to go out alone after midnight, mine do not. Had this affected me in any way possible? Not the least. That’s it. Period.
My mobile phone rang. My mother told me she’s coming to get me. Emmy made another invitation for my mother. I said goodbye. I met my mother at the door who as usual took me to the nearest ice cream restaurant where we have our little chat. There echoed the words of my colleague in my mind, but this time with a wide smile as I was looking at my mother explaining her own adventure, “Thank God for my parents.”
Sameeha Elwan
18 August, 2010
Salam, Sameeha,
Absoultely well said, sister.
This is hitting them below their belt!
I loved your reaction to these so called ”open-minded” folks, mashAllah.
Their open mindedness should be in kept in check before their brains fall out!
Yeah, let them go prattling and making fun of you, they are the ones who feel inferior and not you.
No matter how hard they try, they cannot make you feel so, as you are proud to be who you are and you adhere firmly to the laws of ISLAM which isn’t just a CUSTOM or CULTURE but a RELIGIION.
If it was a Gazan custom or culture then I don’t think MY parents would be one and the same, as I come to find that we have many things in common.
I guess these people would surely put my brother under that same ”pity you and lucky me” phrase as he too is NOT allowed to go out alone after hours.
So imagine what they will have to that…
Who the hell cares, it is our life and NOT theirs, so why so much of feigned confern?!
As you sad: ”Thanks GOD for my parents”
Excellent!
Good for you Sameeha, for taking a stand. For a long time I dealt with such issues when I was living and reporting in Gaza, and interacting with many foreign journalists.
Indeed, you are the lucky one!
“. I have never let darkness assume its control over my own life ”
i like this Sentence too much and what i like in you how do you look at the obstacles in a positive way .
any ways .. I really enjoyed reading your article although it was very difficult .
Good luck
Pingback: Gaza’s Social Network: Gazan bloggers share the reality of the siege with the world
I love your blog, and I love this entry! You are SO RIGHT. I am an American who lived for five months in Gaza earlier this year, and so many of my friends quizzed me when I returned about the oppression of Gazan women! They just would not believe me when I said that they aren’t being forced to wear the hijab by their husbands…
I will be returning to Gaza Jan 8 or so. I’d love to meet you….
It would be great meeting you, too, Pam
Well said!!!
Thank you
Hey…I’d love to see you write a blog with other advice for internationals..things we do wrong, stupid things we say, what we need to understand..lol
Samehha,
I enjoyed your candor and revelled in your up-front-ness with the internationals. Still, don’t judge them too harshly. They are coming from a different reality. I too come from a different reality than the culture inwhich I live. But when I was young, I just used to go home silently with a knot in my stomach, afraid to speak out. So good for you. Be loving but firm. People just need to learn.
Also, when I was in Gaza a couple of years ago, I encountered exactly the same attitude with some of the women who went with the group. Here it was, the Palestinians in Gaza had just suffered inmensly, many of you living in tents, fearing for your life from the Zionists in your occupied land, suffering family deaths and all they could think of was to keep pressuring the different women we interviewed to tell them just exactly how in fact the women were suffereing abuse or being subjected to sexism. The people, mostly women, whom we talked with kept repeateing gently that yes, to be sure, there were some problems in that area, but at present your greatest problems were the tyranny brought on by the Israeli Zionists, lack of clean water, extreme weather and a destroyed parts of the city. I don’t know if they understood, but I did.
Bless you dearest child. Nothing lasts forever. We here will continue to support you in whatever way we can.
Keep blogging
Exactly, I did not say that Gaza is free of all kind of oppression. To some extent that is not true. Gaza is like any other place in the world where some women still face difficulties in their lives, but the issue is in the matter of generalisation. They assume all of us are oppressed, and all of us are submissive when this is not true. Another issue is that they do focus on some matters, which as you said is trivial, when compared to the other hardships faced by the Occupation. They do not ask for our right to travel whenever we want, nor our right to go out for education which is absolutely not given to us, but they would complain why women have to wear uniforms for the Islamic university or why they cannot smoke Shisha or why they can’t go on dates, for example, forgetting it’s a total different culture
Thanks for your comment Juliane
I’m an elderly English man who has lived in Australia for many years, and who will be coming to visit Gaza for a few days with Code Pink early in February.
I agree with Pam Bailey’s post; I also would like advice on how I should best behave when I am in your country and culture. It is me who should adapt and respect you rather than the other way around.
Regards, Alex Bell
It would be a great pleasure meeting you, sir.
I’ll just say what I said to Pam on this matter
I don’t think I can make a list of what internationals should get or shouldn’t. After all, most of internationals come to Gaza seeking to know; that is something I truely appreciate. I just wish that they wouldn’t come with some preconceptions which might blur the right clear picture; preconceptions which sometimes they try to prove rather than investigate its being true.
Dear Sameeha,
I am an American of Lebanese descent on my paternal (father’s) side and lived in Gaza for three months, taught at Al Azhar University, and gave lectures also at Al Quds University (Jerusalem branch) and Islamic University to graduate students (majister in Arabbiya) and faculty. I also volunteered as a research analyst at Gaza Community Mental Health. Of course, being second generation American on both sides, my mother and my father, I am quite independent (owned several businesses) and when travelling if you have no family or friend support you must go on your own. But even though I am conflicted between my Arab-American heritage and American, I understand the concern. My parents were always concerned where I was. My Lebanese father always would comment, “Daughter, when I want to hear from you I don’t hear from you (this would be late at night if he could not reach me, he was terribly worried) and when I don’t want to hear from you, I hear from you (I was so attached to my father, I would call him and my mother like 10 times a day). Although I am not religious, my extended Lebanese family and my ex husband, born in Lebanon, were Christian, among Arabs, religion does not matter in this respect, family is everything, and we always want a companion with us when we travel at night, abroad, anywhere. This is how we live. So don’t have to make excuses to internationals. Even though I consider myself rugged and have had to be tough living in the U.S. and my Lebanese grandmother as well, as her first husband, my grandfather left her with my father and aunt, and she had to peddle linens and then remarried to an abusive Lebanese physician in Buffalo New York, I still like the attention my Palestinian students showered on me. After class at Al Azhar U, they would carry my heavy computer case. In U.S. culture you would call me a wuzz, “a weakling”, broadly translated, but it was nice that they took the time from their busy schedule to do this.
Like your blog like Pam and Alex. I too will be accompanying Dr. Alex Bell on our trip at the end of January to Gaza. Salaam,
Diane Shammas
Hi Sameeha,
I met so many wonderful women in Gaza when I was there. This worrying about women’s rights would be the last thing on my mind if I had an enemy trying to erase my people.
I remember one time as we were traveling in the bus along a stretch where we could see the border and some of the women in our group were forcefully trying to get the bus driver to pull over and stop so they could take pictures. He politely said no and our guides interpreted saying it was not safe. I trusted the bus driver knew very well what was and was not safe. These women exercised their empowerment in a rather demanding way, as if they knew better than some Palestinian bus driver whose judgment they were not respecting in the least. I recall exchanging glances back and forth with some of our female guides. What good is empowerment and a sense of equality when it can be exercised stupidly and get you killed. Later, I thanked the bus driver for not stopping and keeping us safe.
When I was a teenager my parents didn’t let me go out at night alone or to roam the streets with my friends. Are you crazy!
annie
Dear Annie,
Your comment has made me realize I made a mistake calling the blog “International”. My mistake was in making generalization. Not all internationals are the same for sure, though a large number is. I do appreciate every person who come in solidarity with Palestine for the sake of freedom and peace. My respect and love for you, dear.
Thank you
sameeha, the amazing helena cobban had this to say about the ‘oppression’ of women in gaza:
… I am disappointed to see these two generally respected members of the generally wise “Elders” group engaging in this imperialistic kind of faux “feminism”… that is, the articulation by people strongly connected with the west (and that now certainly includes my old friend Lakhdar Brahimi) of a “particular” concern for the plight of the women living in non-western societies, based on the divisive argument that their own menfolk (based on their alleged backwardness, etc) repress them just as badly as their western colonial occupiers do.
Certainly the French used to adduce just exactly this same argument to help support the conceit that they were pursuing a mission civilisatrice in Brahimi’s own native Algeria, back in the day. It is really disappointing to see him dragging it out of the attic now, 50 years later.
but i recommend the whole link. helena has a new publishing company, she is publishing Laila El-Haddad’s first book, Gaza Mom: Palestine, Politics, Parenting, and Everything In Between. she has lots of excellent links on her website and has been reporting on palestine for decades.
the propaganda drumbeat of ‘powerless women in islamic society’ is a warfare strategy. one (unfortunately) many people here believe. we were told we were going to iraq to ‘liberate’ the women. (of course we had to kill at least a million iraqis to do it and guess what? they are not liberated yet!) it is a ‘foot in the door’ to justify our amazing ‘western liberating ways’ and it never ceases to amaze me how people jump on this bandwagon as a way to ‘sympathize’ w/oppressed women, as if the blockade wasn’t oppressive!
anyway, i met so many smart impressive women in gaza, everywhere i went.
but the real reason i went is because people take you more seriously here when you advocate for free palestine if you have actually been there and can speak about the true reality (which includes amazingly empowering women if you ask me).
the entire US mainstream press is a complete zionist entity. but, the good news is more and more people are getting there news from the web, and we are rocking their world and they know it. palestine is HUGE on campuses all across the county, HUGE. whereas when i was young i had never even heard of palestinians. it’s the new generation, they are not ‘getting’ the zionist justification for ethnic cleansing. the entire dynamic of the internet conversation has radically changed the discourse since the gaza massacre. and the most amazing part you might ask? the zionists are loosing the next generation…of american jews.
lots of people here are working very hard to free palestine, lots. despite the billions of dollars that go into buying off members of congress, we are making a dent.
hang in there, you are holding up the world.
Pingback: Блогъри от Газа « Give me justice first, the peace will follow…
So proud of your response to your colleagues! You should never feel bad about who you are or the values you have. Never let anyone make you feel inferior. Your parents love you and worry about you, and it wasn’t that long ago when the streets of Gaza were not safe for neither men nor women at any time of the day. I respect your parents for their concern for you and I think they are totally justified. You are a lucky girl to have such caring parents
I met Chantal when I was in Gaza this past winter and she seemed pretty open to the differences between European “openness” and Arab “traditionalism,” she may have just been trying to coax an answer out of you that she felt you were too shy to give..
Sameeha,
Salam
Nice to meet you in Halifax the other day, i hope to send you one of Nadia’s stories and also something about your studies as I am also interested in the Other… but I misplaced your papers…inshallah I’ll find them… All I can say is, after twenty years of coming into contact with Arabic culture I have discovered some great things I never came across before, my all-time favourite is alhamdulillah 3ala kuli haal, ie thanking God in all situations, not just the good ones. And lets face it, since when is Western or modern globalised culture so great for women? If it was great, I wouldn’t have a twelve year old getting up at six am just to spend an hour straightening her hair and doing her makeup and nails before school, and likewise our papers wouldn’t waste an awful lot of ink commenting on women’s appearance, weight, plastic surgery, dress-sense etc etc….